Sunday, October 25, 2026
Live
“
“
Voices from the corridors

Whispers Forum

Debates, reader views and sharp takes on the issues shaping governance — a new conversation every week, archived by date.

0 posts 0 months Latest: 3 Aug 2024
  Browse by date   All posts2833
  2026188
  2025312
  2024310
  2023309
  2022309
  2021300
  2020312
  2019309
  2018295
  2017189

August 2024 27 posts · page 3 of 3

Clear filter
Saturday, 3 August 2024

A book by former Coal Secretary on Coal Sector

This is indeed a rare instance, in fact the only one known to me, when a top Civil Servant chooses to take on himself the task of showcasing the journey of a critical sector like coal through the lens of the successive Captains of the Management Teams that led the development of the sector from the ashes to a vibrant transformed national jewel through tireless efforts over half a century. Sincerely expected the book to be a treasure of knowledge for generations associated with the Coal Sector, past, present and future.
Partha Sarathi Bhattacharyya, former Chairman Coal India Ltd
Friday, 2 August 2024

Many approach entrance tests without joining coaching

Aspirants must try to study without joining coaching. I agree with Mr Reddy that aspirants for various examinations must try to study without joining coaching institutes. But as I understand, there are very different approaches to school/ college education, competitive exams and entrance tests for MBA etc. While school education gives thorough book knowledge, which is very essential, competitive exams like Civils, etc. tests the knowledge of the candidate as to how he/ she applies the knowledge gained in schools. The next category of MBA entrance tests also tests the same knowledge as is tested in Civil etc exams - but with speed and accuracy. I hope this assessment is correct. At this point, I will disagree with Mr Reddy because applicability of knowledge to tests will need some kind of coaching and guidance, which may come from oneself or parents or coaching institutes. The coaching institutes sharpen the candidates knowledge to apply properly to the subject.
Pradeep
New generation should draw inspiration from 1957 batch IFS officer
Recently, Muchkund Dubey, IFS 57 died at the ripe old age of 90. He was first among all the candidates selected that year (1956 exam). Had he come first today, he would have been hailed all over social media for his feat of topping the exam from conditions of extreme poverty and films might have been made on him. He came from a dirt poor family. As a student, he never had more than one pencil. He bathed at a municipal tap and laid out his only dhoti to dry, wearing just his "gamcha". His Professors at Patna University would provide him with fees and often, a meal. Such was his brilliance that he topped the IAS exam despite the terrible poverty he was mired in. Once in the Indian Foreign Service, he addressed the UN. B K Nehru, ICS is supposed to have remarked that the speech was brilliant but he wished it had been delivered in an Oxbridge accent. Muchkund, the dirt poor Bihari that he had been born as, stuck to his Bihari accent. When he was posted to Bangladesh, he quickly attracted attention. But for that posting, he would never have made it to Foreign Secretary. To all the poor Biharis of that era, he was the example they all would try to emulate. The Civil Services Examination has always attracted talented young men and women from humblest of backgrounds and Muchkund was a very early example of merit defeating extreme poverty.
Vijay Kumar
Thursday, 1 August 2024

Worst-case scenario after assassination of Hamas leader in middle-east

If Iran vows to avenge the assassination of Hamas's political leader Ismail Haniyeh, it may invite third world war? It is believed that Israel killed the Hamas leader in an overnight air strike in Tehran. The killing is just hours after an Israeli strike on the Lebanese capital Beirut killing Hezbollah commander.
Sunil kumar